- Hertz EV depreciation has elevated by 89%, reaching $537 per automotive, per 30 days
- The automotive rental company is dedicated to promoting off 30,000 of its EVs by the top of 2024
- Used automotive patrons can snag certainly one of Hertz’s pre-owned Tesla Mannequin 3s for beneath $20,000
Hertz’s pioneering of EVs as rental vehicles appeared foolproof—much less upkeep and a decrease whole price of possession are two issues that any firm competing within the rental house strives for. However as Hertz shortly came upon, its grand experiment went horribly mistaken. It is now grow to be a large clearance occasion, the place the whole lot should go.
The corporate’s fireplace sale on EVs has been ongoing for months. The purpose? Dump at the least 30,000 EVs—which embody vehicles from Tesla and different manufacturers like Polestar—by the top of the 12 months. In the end, Hertz desires to retain solely sufficient automobiles to fulfill the demand of the renters who’re truly reserving journeys in battery-powered vehicles to keep away from hefty hits on depreciating stock. Now, after a weak earnings report, Hertz is accelerating its sale of Tesla fashions.Â
Hertz is at present promoting its surplus Teslas on its web site. On the time of writing, it is doable to get into one of many former rental vehicles for beneath $20,000, not together with the $4,000 federal tax credit score on used EVs. So which means a high-mileage Mannequin 3 for round $15,000. Price it? We’ll allow you to be the decide.

Hertz plans to proceed its purge by way of 2025, which implies a continued try and cease the bleed whereas used EV values proceed to slide. Thankfully, that magic quantity appears to be anyplace between Hertz’s noticed low of round $20,000 to the magic tax credit score variety of $25,000, so at the least the losses seem like considerably predictable.
How did it come to this? Again in 2021, Hertz determined to “go inexperienced.” The rental automotive company would begin including EVs to its fleet, starting with a pledge for a large order of 100,000 Tesla Mannequin 3s. Whereas Hertz by no means truly reached that quantity, the concept in itself was a sensible transfer. Clients cherished it and the corporate, in principle, solely needed to pay for easy fixes like tires and washer fluid—that is the entire EV shtick, in any case, fewer transferring elements means much less maintenance.
Nonetheless, Hertz started hurting with the remainder of Tesla patrons as soon as the electrical automaker started slashing costs in a single day which despatched depreciation skyrocketing and sparked Hertz’s enormous sell-off.

One of many methods the Hertz’s worth is measured is with its belongings—you realize, its vehicles. The issue is, that whenever you put money into tens of 1000’s of vehicles at peak pricing and the producer drops the worth drastically a number of instances throughout possession, your organization loses some huge cash in a short time. In actual fact, Hertz estimates that EV depreciation throughout its fleet is up 89%, amounting to a staggering $537 per automotive, per 30 days.
It is not simply new automotive costs and slowing used EV demand that is driving issues. It seems that these Teslas aren’t precisely saving cash like Hertz deliberate, both. Restore prices have been a problem, and it seems that Hertz-owned Teslas had been entering into quite a few collisions, resulting in excessive restoration prices and lead instances.
These points mixed have resulted in hundreds of thousands of {dollars} in losses over the past 4 quarters and satisfied Hertz’s new CEO to unload the overwhelming majority of its EV fleet.
One of many greater unknowns is the place this leaves the EV and automotive rental industries. Each appear to be at odds for the reason that Hertz deal and now issues are enjoying out like a messy divorce between the 2. Ultimately, as EVs grow to be extra well-liked, automotive rental businesses might want to discover a technique to higher handle a fleet of EVs and taper the expectations of losses. Maybe it is a preview of what is to return—or possibly only a teething situation of companies studying easy methods to change with the instances.
Both method, it spells out some good offers for anybody available in the market for a used rental automotive.